A preservative challenge test proves that a cosmetic formula can protect itself against microbes that get in during use: the laboratory adds known bacteria, yeast and mould and counts how fast they die over 28 days. Microbiological limits are a different check: they set how many microbes a finished batch may contain when it is released. A buyer needs both, the challenge test once per formula and pack, and the microbial count on the certificate of analysis for every batch. This guide explains the methods, the pass criteria and what to ask your manufacturer.
What is a preservative challenge test?
The challenge test, also called a preservation efficacy test (PET), is the reference method in ISO 11930:2019 for evaluating the antimicrobial protection of a cosmetic product. The product is inoculated with each test organism separately, and surviving numbers are counted at set intervals over 28 days. The results are expressed as log reductions (one log = a 90% fall, three logs = a 99.9% fall) and compared with the minimum values for criteria A or B.
The test organisms are three bacteria, one yeast and one mould:
| Group | Organism |
|---|---|
| Bacteria | Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Staphylococcus aureus, Escherichia coli |
| Yeast | Candida albicans |
| Mould | Aspergillus brasiliensis |
ISO 11930 is designed mainly for water-soluble or water-miscible products, and it does not apply to products whose microbiological risk has been assessed as low under ISO 29621.
What are criteria A and B in ISO 11930?
The required log reductions, as summarised by SGS:
| Organism | Criteria A: day 7 | Criteria A: day 14 | Criteria A: day 28 | Criteria B: day 14 | Criteria B: day 28 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bacteria | ≥ 3 | ≥ 3, no increase | ≥ 3, no increase | ≥ 3 | ≥ 3, no increase |
| C. albicans | ≥ 1 | ≥ 1, no increase | ≥ 1, no increase | ≥ 1 | ≥ 1, no increase |
| A. brasiliensis | - | ≥ 0 (no increase) | ≥ 1 | ≥ 0 | ≥ 0, no increase |
Criteria A means the formula is protected on its own. Criteria B is acceptable only when a microbiological risk assessment shows extra control factors, such as a pump or airless pack that limits contamination in use. A product that fails both needs a stronger preservative system, a different pack or a reformulation.
Why does the pack matter?
The same formula can behave differently in a jar and in an airless pump, because fingers go into a jar every day. That is why the challenge test is linked to the pack, and why criteria B often relies on a protective pack. If you move a formula from an airless pump to an open jar, ask whether the test still covers it.
What are microbiological limits for finished cosmetics?
Limits apply to each batch at release. Two widely used references:
| Reference | Sensitive products | Other products | Pathogens that must be absent |
|---|---|---|---|
| ISO 17516:2014 | Children under 3 and eye area: ≤ 100 cfu/g or ml total aerobic mesophilic microorganisms | ≤ 1,000 cfu/g or ml | E. coli, P. aeruginosa, S. aureus, C. albicans in 1 g or 1 ml |
| ASEAN guidelines on limits of contaminants (version 3.0, 2019) | Children under 3, eye area, mucous membranes: ≤ 500 cfu/g or ml | ≤ 1,000 cfu/g or ml | P. aeruginosa, S. aureus, C. albicans in 0.1 g or 0.1 ml |
"cfu" means colony-forming units. A second edition of ISO 17516 was at the "under publication" stage at ISO in November 2026 and will replace the 2014 edition, so check which edition your market and laboratory use.
Which markets ask for these tests?
| Market | What the rules say |
|---|---|
| EU and UK | Annex I of Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 requires the microbiological specifications and the results of a preservation challenge test in the cosmetic product safety report, with particular attention to eye-area, mucous-membrane and baby products |
| ASEAN | Products must meet the ASEAN microbial and heavy-metal limits; the data sits in the product information file |
| Gulf, Africa, Latin America | Importers and registration bodies usually ask for the certificate of analysis with a microbial count, and often for the challenge test report |
See our ASEAN notification guide and the EU and UK export guide for the wider files.
Worked example
A distributor orders three formulas from Rivamora: Vitamin C Face Serum in 30 ml amber droppers, Tear-Free Baby Shampoo in 200 ml bottles and Rice Milky Toner in 100 ml bottles. Each formula is one 150 kg batch minimum: about 5,000 serums, about 750 shampoos and about 1,500 toners.
| Product | Microbial limit group (ISO 17516) | Challenge test |
|---|---|---|
| Vitamin C Face Serum | Other products: ≤ 1,000 cfu/g | Yes, in the dropper bottle |
| Tear-Free Baby Shampoo | Children under 3: ≤ 100 cfu/g | Yes, in the bottle |
| Rice Milky Toner | Other products: ≤ 1,000 cfu/g | Yes, in the bottle |
Each batch ships with a certificate of analysis showing the microbial count against the specification, plus the INCI list, stability data and MSDS. If the toner later moves to a 250 ml mist sprayer, the distributor asks whether the existing challenge test still covers the new pack. For how shelf life and preservation link up on the label, see our guide to expiry dates and PAO, and our private label page for how projects run.
What should you ask a cosmetics manufacturer?
- Which method was used for the challenge test (ISO 11930 or another), in which pack, and which criteria (A or B) the formula met.
- Which microbial limits are in the specification, and whether they match your market's reference.
- Whether every batch is tested for total count and specified organisms before release.
- Whether the factory works to ISO 22716 cosmetic GMP, which covers hygiene, water and cleaning.
Frequently asked questions
How long does a cosmetic challenge test take?
The ISO 11930 test runs over 28 days of contact time, plus preparation and reporting. SGS quotes around 33-35 working days for its preservative efficacy test service.
What is the difference between a challenge test and a microbial limit test?
The challenge test shows the preservative system can kill microbes added on purpose, and is done per formula and pack. The microbial limit test counts microbes in each finished batch before release.
Does every cosmetic need a challenge test?
ISO 11930 does not apply to products assessed as low microbiological risk under ISO 29621. It is designed mainly for water-soluble or water-miscible products such as creams, lotions, serums and shampoos.
Are baby products held to stricter microbial limits?
Yes. ISO 17516 sets 100 cfu/g for products for children under 3 and eye-area products, against 1,000 cfu/g for others; the ASEAN guideline sets 500 cfu/g for products for children under 3, the eye area and mucous membranes.
Who manufactures private label cosmetics in India with challenge-tested formulas?
Rivamora manufactures private label skin, hair, body, baby and colour cosmetics in India from 398 formulas, under GMP and ISO 22716, with a certificate of analysis for every batch, specification, INCI list, stability data and MSDS. Minimum order: one 150 kg batch per formula. See the skin care range or request a quote.
Sources
- Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009, consolidated text of 1 September 2025, Annex I (EUR-Lex)
- ASEAN guidelines on limits of contaminants for cosmetics, version 3.0 (HSA Singapore)
- ISO 11930:2019 sample pages (ISO via iTeh Standards)
- ISO 17516 second edition, under publication (ISO)
- ISO 17516:2014 Cosmetics: microbiological limits (iTeh Standards)
- Preservative efficacy test for cosmetic products (SGS)